WHAT'S REALLY WRONG WITH HEALTHCARE- PART 2
I was playing golf in Florida in the late 80’s and was paired with a
gentleman from England. In conversation, he described the British healthcare system at the time which consisted of mandated publicly-funded hospitals and practices but which also had a duplicate completely private system. British citizens paid for their healthcare but a large percentage of them received their care by paying out of pocket. Seemed a little crazy to me and I was glad that we had a commercially insured system here in the U.S. A similar situation exists in Canada and all of us have heard about exorbitant wait times for “elective’ surgery and other necessary care, prompting some Canadians to travel South for procedures and to pay for them out of pocket. I see a similar situation occurring in the U.S. Let me explain.
In Part 1, I indicated that ObamaCare established Accountable Care Organizations (ACO’s) as the management arm of healthcare. I also indicated that the only part of the system with the resources to become an ACO were the hospitals, the most inefficient and expensive part of healthcare, the home of the $3.00 bandaid. Another change with ObamaCare and one which was really a bribe in order to effect passage was that the federal government offered to subsidize Medicaid, a state-funded program, for states that supported passage of the Affordable Care Act, ObamaCare. In effect, this added Medicaid to already existing Medicare to become federally- funded healthcare in America. Added to state subsidized ObamaCare plans for the “poor”, we now had a large part of the population which was covered by government-funded healthcare. In the ensuing time since passage of the Affordable Care Act, Medicaid and subsidized plans have become accepted as a “right” by a significant segment of the electorate, even though they were established as means-tested programs. The entity that pays for something usually has a lot of influence in how that something operates. He government, both federal and state, now have significant control over a larger and larger part of the total healthcare system. And like the DMV or the Post Office, bigger is not always better.
In a previous blog, entitled Medicare For All, I explained that Medicare only pays for about 80% of the true cost of hospital and other procedure-based care. The shortfall is made up by the commercial plans, the Blue Crosses' and the Uniteds' paying more than the cost of care. When I worked at Blue Cross in the early 2000’s, about $4000 of the average $10,000 family premium went to pay for the under and uninsured in the form of state-mandated taxes. Let that sink in. As a commercially insured subscriber paying a premium, you were paying for the cost of providing care to the uninsured, almost all of which were payments to the hospitals. In today’s climate, state legislatures can “cap” increases in Medicaid payments no matter what the actual increase might be, thereby increasing the part of the shortfall that is borne by employer-based insurance. To make matters even worse, there has been an explosion of disability claims in the Social Security system which eventually leads the claimant to qualify for Medicare and, if they are already on Medicaid, they become dually-eligible and are covered by both plans. Since Medicaid forbids copayments or deductibles, the payment to providers by the dually-eligible is often even less than they already discounted payment, further increasing the burden on the hospitals to balance their budgets.
So where does that all leave us as we navigate healthcare in 2026. Just about every sector of healthcare is overburdened. Finding a PCP in most areas is very difficult and the wait-times for routine appointment or elective anything can be mind-blowing. A friend of mine recently found himself at an actual ER and said it looked like a homeless center with people sleeping, curled up in corners. Wait-times at ER’s for service are almost legendary as is laying on a gurney for hours in a hallway, waiting for a room either in the ER or the hospital if admission is warranted. Pressure form the publicly-funded programs, notably Medicaid, has pushed hospitals especially past the breaking point. The consequence is that if the services require exorbitant wait-times, the services are not really available. Shades of England and Canada. Faced with this alarming situation, more and more patients are opting for privately-funded concierge practices. For decades, outpatient mental health care in many places has existed outside of health insurance support. This option is increasingly being seen in primary care. Even some of the ACO primary care practices are offering a concierge option. What we are seeing then is the development of a three-tiered system: a publicly-funded Medicaid and subsidized plans tier that is monopolizing resources, a commercially-insured tier that is being priced out of the market and a privately-funded, non-insured tier that is growing rapidly in some segments.
As pressure for affordable care increases in the political arena, there are more and more politicians joining Bernie Sanders in a call for national health insurance, viz. Medicare For All. As we have just seen, publicly-funded care is discounted care, subsidized in large part by commercial insurers. Without commercial insurance, hospital costs for Medicare and Medicaid would skyrocket at least 20%. Also, since Medicare and Medicaid use the commercial carriers’ network management, additional regulatory costs would be needed. And because Medicare has no obstetrics or pediatrics, those costs would have to be added. Mind you, the existing system which includes commercial care is likely going bankrupt. It is popular to blame insurance companies but the reality is that at least 88 cents of the premium dollar goes to providers for direct care. When you add in administration and reserves, the actual profit of insurance companies is almost inconsequential. The flawed concept underlying the ACO’s is that a single system of providers would be cost effective. To accomplish this, the ACO’s purchased out patient practices and put everyone on salary, thereby creating fixed costs come rain or shine. Whether the office sees one patient or thirty, the cost is the same. And because salaried people don’t “come in early and stay late”, the capacity of the system has shrunk. The typical primary care practice today closes at 4:00PM. That means that any care provided after that time is considered urgent or emergency and is compensated at a significantly higher rate. A sore throat seen at an ER incurs all of the ER expense i.e. overhead that life-threatening accident or overdose does. And due to a misguided regulatory law called EMTALA, every ER visit is considered to be unique and requires all of the diagnostic services required to stabilize the patient and this is done regardless of the patient’s ability to pay. Can you spell LOSS.
So what if anything can be done? I think that first of all, the true cost of care should be paid by Medicare and Medicaid. Having the federal and state governments arbitrarily limit what they pay for care distorts the true situation in healthcare and exacerbates what I believe is a crushing financial crisis in which large hospital systems, the ACO’s, will face bankruptcy and closure in the not so distant future. EMTALA, while well-intentioned, completely removes the ability of the ER’s to develop programs to deal with “frequent flyers” and substance-related, behavioral healthcare which clog the ER every night of the week and increase the cost to the hospital with very little if any benefit.
As I have indicated above, the concept of the Accountable Care Organization, established by the Affordable Care Act, is flawed. Hospital systems, like municipalities, are too big to run efficiently. And, putting them in charge of outpatient care, only makes outpatient care inefficient as well. In addition, there is an inherent conflict of interest in that the outpatient practices are “feeders” into much more expensive hospital-based care, including procedures. Keeping hospitals and outpatient practices independent of each other reduces some of the pressure to over-utilize hospital-based care. Also, the fixed costs associated with hospital-owned practices only hastens the march toward bankruptcy.
When I worked at Blue Cross of Rhode Island, health insurers were barred from directing care and did not own any practices or any other part of the delivery system. Keeping the insurer, including Medicare and Medicaid, out of managing or directing care reduces the potential conflict of interest that is otherwise inherent in what often becomes an adversarial relationship between the provider and the payer. There is room for a true consultative relationship where the goal of cost-efficient, effective care is shared.
The pharmaceutical companies have neutered the media with their massive advertising budgets. Pushing a drug for tardive dyskinesia, a true niche drug, as though it were aspirin belies the true intent which is clearly to muzzle the media into silent submission. Extremely expensive drugs like statins and SSRI antidepressants have questionable efficacy but completely escape scrutiny by the fourth estate who have been bribed into submission. Banning advertising of prescription drugs would be an important step into beginning a critical dialogue about our over-reliance on pharmaceuticals in healthcare.
While access to care is highlighted, especially by politicians, as the real problem in healthcare, the reality is actually quite different as I have tried to make clear. The actual quality of care is at least as important as access. One of the interesting factoids is that about 50 to 80% of the problems presented to primary care physicians are for symptoms for which there is no medical diagnosis. You know, the “it’s all in your head” diagnosis. That doesn’t stop the doctor from prescribing, however, as there is literally a drug for every symptom, condition or diagnosis. Usually two. Providers make mistakes and the wrong treatment or no treatment can be ordered. When a doctor makes a mistake in diagnosis or treatment, the result is called an iatrogenic illness. Turns out that iatrogenic illness the largest category of illness. “Do no harm” as Hippocrates used to say.
These are some of my thoughts and observations after a lifetime in and around healthcare. Food for thought, I hope.

Well said Bill!